The Public School Implosion: The Weekly Mentor by Oliver DeMille


Article Correction: Thanks to Bill Peavoy and his friends for pointing out an error in the original posting of this article. Instead of 72% trust of public schools in 1975, the number was actually 29%. This means the downward shift is only 17%, much less than the 60% I previously stated. I clearly wrote down the wrong numbers while studying the polls, and I should have gone back and double-checked it. Dumb. My mistake. Thank you so much for this clarification! It’s a huge difference.

It also points out an interesting idea, one that reverses my view in the original article. I had suggested that trust in public schools went from 72% of the population down to 12%, when in fact for over forty years less than 30% of the U.S. population has held high trust in public schools. The number is now down to 12%, as stated. So the real story is the surprising (at least to me) long-term trend of holding such little trust in our schools.

There is also a significant storyline in the high numbers who now have Very Little or No trust in public schools. In fact, in 1973 only 11% of Americans polled held Very Little or No trust in our public schools, while today 31% have Very Little or No trust in them. ~OD

The Public School Implosion

(A Staggering Shift!)

by Oliver DeMille

I’ve been studying a lot of polls lately, because I’m interested in really understanding the American people, the electorate, and the trends that are currently determining our national future. Not that polls are perfect, by any means. But they do give us important insight into what people are thinking right now.

As I’ve researched, I keep finding interesting little trends in the data. And, at times, I run across some shockingly big realities that will clearly have a major impact on our society. For example, we’ve seen a major shift in the way most Americans think about leading societal institutions.

Just consider what Gallup Polls show about the following changes between 1975 and 2014 in our trust/distrust of major institutions:

Public Schools 29 12
Congress 14 4
The Presidency 23 14
The Supreme Court 20 12
The Health Care/
Medical System
44 17
Church/Organized Religion 43 25

*Source:, 2014

The Stand Out

While the general trend in all these categories is a serious loss of public trust in important institutions, one really stands out: Public Schools. As the following chart shows:

FROM 1975 TO 2014
Congress -10
The Presidency -9
Supreme Court -8
Health Care/Medical System -27
Church/Organized Religion -18
Public Schools -17

*Source: ibid.

This is very telling. We are not only raising a generation of young people whose native language is “Digital” (for many of them, English is literally a second language—as evidenced by youth who stand or sit next to each other in the same room and carry on lengthy conversations by text messages rather than talking aloud), but also a generation whose core language decidedly isn’t Trust.

The Old and New

This is a change from the 1970s, 80s, and 90s schools and neighborhoods where most of today’s parents were raised. While the native Boomer and Generation X language was often skeptical of non-friends, we grew up in an environment where a core trust in our communities of friends, family, and adult supporters still dominated society.

This is no longer the case, at least not to the same extent. The native dialect our children are growing up in now spans the scale from mistrust to distrust to cynicism. This is fueled by any regular contact with the Internet or social media, where a thick skin is a required dialect and disregarding a majority of what you read is just part of a young person’s accent.

The Relevant Conversation

In all this, the biggest loser is childhood, a protected place of safety and acceptance where a young person can grow, find himself/herself, and take the time to explore his/her possible place and role in the world. Technology has significantly shortened this time of natural innocence for nearly all young people.

Wise parents are aware of this, and deal with it head on. Specifically: Talking directly to your children and youth about when and what to trust, and not trust, is certainly as important as language arts, math, science, or history. Such conversations and lessons are often even more relevant and immediate than academics.

About the Author:

Rachel is the co-author of Leadership Education: The Phases of Learning and the audio series Core and Love of Learning: A Recipe for Success, and the author of the award-winning educational resource, This Week in History. She is an accomplished musician, writer, literary editor, public speaker, consultant and momschool organizer.


  1. Carl March 6, 2015 at 9:51 am - Reply

    Great insight Oliver. We’re moving into the age of customization rather than just information. Those who REALLY meet the needs win in this environment. The word of the day is UTILITY. How useful is your product. In terms of public education – the information must be applicable.

    Here is an article exclusively on confidence in public schools.

  2. James Ure March 6, 2015 at 10:12 am - Reply

    Love that you are talking about these trends. I also believe that lack of TRUST is a core problem in public education today. In fact, if teachers, administrators, and legislators made the necessary changes to address the trust problem alone, I think the others would take care of themselves because it would require a helpful and fundamental paradigm shift.

  3. Ali McConville March 6, 2015 at 1:04 pm - Reply

    Mr. DeMille,
    Thank you for sharing your research. A clear confirmation of what we have been discussing at several family gatherings. We are homeschoolers AND have two public teachers in our family. Ironic? I feel that the trust issue in public schools is epidemic. If we read between the lines, mistrust can be found at almost every level. The ruling fixture of my list right now is the relentless compulsion to test. Standardized test. This is signaling to our teachers that we do not trust them and to our students that they should second guess themselves. One test is not enough to “prove” to the seeing is believing crowd. Often there are batteries of tests that disrupt the regular classroom schedule for weeks. This negative double bind message is made worse by the fact that administrators and legislators are prone to changing the testing every year. The belief that if this test didn’t work another one will next year is false. One can see why many are moving from compliance to confusion and finally mistrust. If the public can see the writing on the wall maybe it is time for the public schools to listen. Thanks for all you do for homeschool families. with admiration, Ali McConville

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.