The 6-Point Plan: Advice for New Homeschoolers and Families Needing a “Reset”

I moderate a large online forum where new and seasoned parents, homeschoolers and professional teachers discuss education and learning. Some questions are asked so frequently that I came up with what I call my “go-to advice” for those new to homeschool, or who are changing lanes and need a fresh approach….

Advice for Newbies, and Families Needing a “Reset”!

by Rachel DeMille,

Here’s the deal. So often, I hear, from brand-new homeschoolers:

  • “What curriculum should I buy for my 13-year-old?”
  • “What curriculum should I buy for my 15-year-old?”
  • “My 5-year-old is holding his pencil wrong.”
  • “My 17-year-old hates math.”
  • “My 17-year-old hates me.”
  • “My 10-year-old hates everything about learning.”
  • “Should I buy the same curriculum for all subjects, or research the best one in each subject (math, literature, history, etc.)?”

And then all the other questions on what to buy, how to set up the dining room, and how long to spend on penmanship and math facts follow.

Through all of this there is a sense that the asker is in no state of mind to hear the answer, because she has an inner dialog of panic going on.

The problem is this: The asker is absolutely in earnest, but doesn’t yet know the right questions to ask. It’s like shopping for your first car.

The thing is, for most families, the greatest concern is 1) establishing the relationships so that teaching and learning can take place effectively, and 2) creating an environment where the kids really want to learn. Once these are accomplished learning can flourish. Until they are attended to, all the questions about curriculum, how people hold their pencil, and what’s the best way to teach spelling are a distraction at best, and can actually get in the way of any success.

It’s not that the questions are bad. They’re actually really good questions, but they’re out of order. It’s a little like shopping for tires when you don’t even know what rim size you want, because you still haven’t gotten the new car home.

To find your best fit with homeschool, you need to do first things first.

Once you have created an environment where the parents like homeschooling and the kids love learning, these and the other questions above are pretty easy to answer. And you don’t waste a lot of time, stress, and money buying one curriculum after another and watching all of them fail – simply because the environment undermines every effort.

In decades of personal experience with this, and after observing/mentoring thousands of families in the same process, here are 6 steps that set the stage for a happy and successful homeschool.

DeMille-Almost nothing more powerful1) Simplify.

I would start by simplifying your home – get rid of the things that are just hanging out and bogging you down. It’s way more fun to homeschool when you’re not stressed about mess, you know?

Too often homeschoolers wonder where their day went because they’re scooting from one task to another, and never get past taking care of their home and things.

Donate it to Goodwill, recycle it, gift it, toss it. Simplify!

2) Family Reading.

Do some family reading – 3 nights per week is a good target. Are your kids boys or girls? For girls, maybe start with Little House in the Big Woods, for boys, Little Britches. Either works for a mix, IMHO, and Charlotte’s Web is a good first chapter-book readaloud for younger kids. For littles: Aesop’s Fables, Kipling’s Just So Stories, Winnie the Pooh, Beatrix Potter, Little Bear, etc. Teensy kids do great with simply picture books with beautiful art.  See our list of Classics for more suggestions >>

3) Core Phase Fun.

For littles, just high-quality story books, bubbles, mud, nature walks, etc., make for a great preschool. And, don’t underestimate the power of these same activities to unite the family – even with older kids! See other suggestions here >>

4) Group Activities.

For older kids, make a trip to the library and find out from locals and city offices what museums, historical sites, art, nature, etc., is must-see in your area. Visit the city pool, cultural events, etc.

5) Show Restraint.

Finally, DON’T spend a lot of money yet. Get your footing. Your questions will be different a month from now; your family will be different six months from now. If you *do* buy something that doesn’t suit you, don’t try to get your money’s worth! Move on! You’ve got the prerogative to wait a time before “school officially starts”- it doesn’t have to be “formal” or official-looking to be valuable, especially at first. Ease into having a more direct hand in the intellectual life of your family. A little less TV, time off from electronics, a lot more doing stuff together, from family work to physical play.

Fairytale-Simplicity copyAs you rebuild family culture, you’ll have a better sense of what you’re looking for out of the resources you might spend money on, and have totally different questions than you do right now. There’s time to figure it all out.

Most people will tell you that “detoxing” is a really valuable place to start, so even though you may have envisioned doing “school”, you may find that you’re still getting great benefit from reading to them while they do puzzles, doing projects in the kitchen, visiting local sites, etc., and not trying to duplicate “school at home.”

It really helps, when kids are recently out of public school, to stay in motion for a while, together as a group – home-based projects (cooking, building, puzzles, physical play), field trips, etc. These activities really help them to sort of come down from the rhythm they’re used to of always having their day scheduled.

If you want our help with a group-learning program for your family that will help you fill your days with interesting new thoughts, projects, people and ideas while get your footing, see our award-winning This Week in History >>

6) Lead Out.

Next thought, and this one is important: Give yourself permission to spend a little bit of time each day/week on YOUR education. The investment in yourself pays off in SOOOO many ways. 1) You set an example of self-education that pays dividends of them owning their own education. That’s less effort for you, more success for them! 2) It will give you a well to draw from. You’ll think bigger thoughts! Have more inspiring ideas that you’re excited to share! Feel taken care of because you’re filling YOUR bucket!

Remember, an investment in your education is not a withdrawal from your kids’. It will pay dividends on a gold standard for generations to come!

TJEd is also known as “Leadership Education.” And the leader in LE is not *just* the kid that grows up in your home under these principles; it’s you! YOU lead out and show them the way. You get excited about education – not just for theirs, but for yours.

If TJEd is calling to you, I would not recommend “winging” it. Don’t just copy a friend, or browse and guess. Do your homework. Our Mentoring in the Classics/TJEd Implementation course is designed specifically to help you become a self-guided learner, design your ideal family education culture, become conversant in the language of the classics, and really *own* the principles of Leadership Education so you can be your own expert. Check it out >>

Once these 6 things are well established, you’ll start to see positive changes in things you didn’t know could change. Your 13yo will smile more. Your 10yo will be cuddly when nobody is looking. Your kids will treat each other with more affection and respect. You’ll start to relax and notice that learning is happening all the time!

These might seem like great advancements for family relations, but actually it’s even more than that. These changes you’ll notice mean that you and your kids are primed for serious learning. These things create an environment where parents love homeschooling, kids love learning, and teens love studying. In such an environment, the rest of your work will be so much easier, and you’ll be ready for new questions, more questions.

And we’re here to help!


Hugs to all you new and/or struggling homeschoolers! I’ve been lamenting lately that lots of new homeschoolers really punish themselves, and, unwittingly, their kids, for not fitting some ideal that’s not actually ideal for them. Please don’t be so hard on yourselves!

Take a day off and go to a park, or the library, or play board games. Do something you love. Cultivate smiles and hugs. Tomorrow is another day.

Please know that pretty much all successful homeschoolers really wandered a little at first trying to find their ideal. And I don’t know any really successful homeschoolers who are super set in their ways. They’re open minded, and always asking new and different questions on how to improve.

Your family is organic, and dynamic, and your homeschool ideal will be, too. Be patient with the process! You’re not going to ruin them or break them, and there really is plenty of time to figure it out.

Don’t hurry up to follow a path that feels wrong. Slow down, stop, turn around, enjoy the moment. You’re going to be fine! ♥ ♥ ♥

You don’t have to be perfect to be spectacular.

Parents and educators all over the world are making a positive difference by integrating idealistic principles into their family culture. The transition isn’t immediate, but in some important ways the results are. Within just a few days’ time a new level of hope and vision can be sensed; over time, and with the incorporation of more and more principles, confidence can be gained that hoped-for changes are on the horizon.
xoxo rd

Rachel DeMille,
“An Education to Match Your Mission”

Want live support and mentoring from seasoned TJEders? Join our Discussion Group, personally moderated by Rachel DeMille >>

About the Author:

Rachel is the co-author of Leadership Education: The Phases of Learning and the audio series Core and Love of Learning: A Recipe for Success, and the author of the award-winning educational resource, This Week in History. She is an accomplished musician, writer, literary editor, public speaker, consultant and momschool organizer.


  1. Sheralee January 17, 2015 at 4:03 pm - Reply

    Thank you! After studying TJEd for six years, I finally took the plunge and became a NEWBIE myself in September. I have been the panic-stricken mother, and I have found my greatest peace when I study (again!) those principles you have captured so well in TJED, Phases of Learning, and your other insightful training. I am finally disciplining myself to stress less about my little students and dedicate daily time to resurrecting my learning muscles. You are so right; it fills my bucket, and then I have something to share that lights fires under my little ones. Truly, the only real education is self-education. You have helped me reclaim my focus, sanity, and vision. Thank you!

  2. M. Sánchez June 17, 2016 at 7:17 am - Reply

    Perhaps it should be obvious to me but, I’m wondering how all of this wonderful steps work in a family with a dysfunctional marriage.

    • Rachel DeMille June 21, 2016 at 7:34 am - Reply

      This is indeed a great impediment to the family’s happiness and well-being. My heart goes out to those who struggle under such a burden! In most cases I urge that the person who’s trying to implement an educational ideal in the context of a troubled marriage identify a hierarchy of goods. The highest ideal would be, in most people’s minds, to be able to heal the marriage relationship. This is because, for as long as that pillar of familial support and modeling is ailing, it can compete with the other goods on the list. And it should. Even ending the marriage doesn’t end the conflict; it doesn’t make it easier to implement an educational ideal when you now have the kids under court supervision and in two separate homes where they are getting two strong messages and the parental pillar continues to bring additional negativity.

      I should far prefer a situation where a couple finds balance and mutual respect in their marriage while putting away the goals of alternative education, than a couple who finds their marriage and family in peril while pursuing TJEd. It may not be that this is the clear choice; but where it is, I don’t hesitate to urge that the questioner put the utmost priority on healing the marriage while doing what he or she reasonably can to address the other needs in the family. There are several books that I would recommend that can help IMMEASURABLY, in my experience (and according to the reports of others who have shared their experience in things of this nature):

      My love and prayers to you and all whose hearts are despairing under a painful load to bear. I do believe, and have seen, that much improvement can be made in these situations when the principles taught in the above books are implemented. It may still not be ideal, but the difference makes a difference, and is worth it. Truly worth it.

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.